A MOMENT FOR YOU
What’s one small step you can take today?
No perfect answers. Just a little room to reflect.
By Daniel J. Callahan, DSW, LMSW, ICRC-ADC
After a hard fight, a slip, or a conversation you walked out of, your body may vote for distance even when the relationship still matters. The chair feels safer than the table. The phone feels heavier than it should. Isolation starts to look like protection.
That pattern showed up in my inbox this morning. Maria Popova’s midweek Marginalian newsletter resurfaced her 2024 essay on polyvagal theory, rupture, repair, and reciprocity. It is a literary essay, not a new study and not a training course. Even so, it is a good prompt for a careful look at polyvagal theory and recovery.
I want to be careful with it. The theory is popular in counseling rooms, and some of its language is useful. Parts of the underlying science are also seriously debated. We can take the relationship ideas seriously without treating the theory as settled fact.
What the essay is pointing to
Popova draws on the psychiatrist Stephen Porges, who developed polyvagal theory, and on the clinical psychologist Deb Dana, who has written about using it in therapy. In plain terms, the theory says our sense of safety and danger is not only a thought. It is also a body state, shaped in part by the vagus nerve, the long nerve that helps regulate things like heart rate and digestion.
The essay highlights a few ideas that many therapists find practical:
- We need other people. Feeling connected is not a luxury.
- Early experiences of being soothed, or not being soothed, can shape how quickly we later read a room as safe or threatening.
- After trauma, the body may default to protection: shutting down, going numb, or pulling away.
- “The mind narrates what the nervous system knows. Story follows state,” Dana writes. In other words, a tense body often writes a tense story.
- Repair can happen in relationships that have real give-and-take, what she calls reciprocity. If early rupture was the template, though, a person may accept one-sided relationships and call them fair.
That last point should sound familiar if you have ever stayed too long in a lopsided friendship, or if you have loved someone through addiction and wondered why “sorry” never seemed to stick. It also cuts the other way. People in early recovery sometimes read a delayed text as rejection, or a quiet partner as proof they have already ruined everything.
I wrote about that kind of invented story in Thoughts Aren’t Facts! and in Feelings Aren’t Facts! A feeling is real. The story we attach to it is not automatically a fact.
What the science actually supports
Some of this sits on solid ground, even if you never mention the vagus nerve.
The vagus nerve is real, and it is an important part of the autonomic nervous system, the system that quietly handles heart rate, digestion, and other automatic functions. Nobody serious disputes that.
Social connection is also not a soft extra. In a 2010 meta-analysis in PLOS Medicine, Julianne Holt-Lunstad, Timothy B. Smith, and J. Bradley Layton reviewed 148 studies and found that stronger social relationships were associated with a 50% greater likelihood of survival. That is one reason isolation is so dangerous in addiction, and why showing up for one another matters so much in recovery. I wrote about that need for give-and-take in Lonely No More!
Rupture and repair is also a useful way to talk about ordinary relationship work. Couples, families, and counseling relationships break and mend all the time. You do not need a new theory of evolution to know that a repaired conversation often beats a perfect one that never happened.
Trauma and the urge to use can also travel together. I looked at that recently in a post on PTSD and alcohol, where a trauma reminder raised the pull to drink for some people, especially those who tend to act quickly when they feel upset. The body state comes first. The next move is still a choice, and skills can be learned.
Where polyvagal theory is debated
Here is the part I do not want to gloss over.
Porges laid out the theory in papers such as “The polyvagal perspective,” published in Biological Psychology in 2007. In broad strokes, he described two vagal pathways: an older dorsal pathway, said to be involved in shutdown, and a later ventral pathway, said to support social engagement and a sense of safety. Popular summaries, including Popova’s essay, sometimes present that map as if it were settled science. It isn’t.
In 2023, also in Biological Psychology, the psychophysiologist Paul Grossman published a detailed critique, “Fundamental challenges and likely refutations of the five basic premises of the polyvagal theory.” He argues that several core claims, including the idea that distinct dorsal and ventral vagal pathways uniquely control heart rate and map neatly onto shutdown versus social behavior, are untenable or highly implausible given the available physiology. He also cautions against treating a heart-rate pattern called respiratory sinus arrhythmia as if it were the same thing as “vagal tone,” or proof of a social-engagement circuit.
Porges and others have replied, and the disagreement is ongoing. I am not going to pretend I can referee a debate among autonomic physiologists. What I can do is be honest with you: polyvagal theory is a popular clinical framework, not a closed scientific case. Some of its evolutionary story, the tight mapping of two vagal pathways onto shutdown versus connection, and casual talk about “rewiring the vagus” or “resetting your nervous system” go beyond what the evidence can carry.
A few lines in the essay should be handled the same way. The claim that every thought, feeling, and mood is “executed by your vagus nerve” is too sweeping to be accurate. “Neuroception,” Porges’s word for the body’s below-awareness detection of safety or danger, is a coined term, not an independently established mechanism. And “reciprocity is a function of the ventral vagus” is a theoretical statement, not a finding you can take to the bank.
None of that makes the relationship advice useless. It just means we should not dress a helpful metaphor in a lab coat and call it a fact.
What this means in recovery
Addiction is hard on connection. Using isolates people. So does shame. So do the fights, the broken promises, and the days when everyone in the house is bracing for the next blowup. Families get exhausted. People in recovery get scared of their own history. A small rupture can feel like the end of the story.
If Dana is right about one thing, even as a metaphor, it is this: when the body is in a protective state, the mind will often write a protection story. “They don’t want me there.” “I already ruined it.” “It’s safer if I just stay gone.” The story may arrive so fast it feels like a fact.
You do not have to buy the whole theory to pause there. Notice the body. Notice the story. Then decide the next right repair, if a repair is safe and warranted.
Repair is usually smaller than people think. It can be walking back into the room. Sending a short text. Saying, “I got overwhelmed, and I want to try that conversation again.” For a family member, it can be, “I’m still here,” without a lecture and without trying to manage the other person’s feelings for them. You can offer a steady presence. You cannot be someone else’s nervous system.
One caution, especially for families: if early harm taught someone to accept one-sided relationships, “repair” should not mean going back to a situation that is unsafe. Distance can be wise. Professional help is wise when trauma, violence, or a long pattern of harm is part of the picture.
Five ways to practice rupture and repair
- Name the break, not the courtroom case. “We got sharp with each other after dinner” is enough. You do not need a closing argument.
- Check the body before you send the message. Hunger, anger, loneliness, and exhaustion make every story sound truer than it is. Drink some water. Step outside. Then look at the situation again.
- Make one small repair the same day when you can. A short call beats a perfect speech you never give. If the other person is not ready, leave the door open and do not chase.
- Watch for the fake version of reciprocity. If you are doing all the apologizing, all the checking in, and all the work, that is not give-and-take. Repair should travel in both directions over time.
- Get skilled help when the wound is old or deep. A counselor who understands trauma and addiction can help you practice connection without asking you to swallow a disputed theory as gospel. If you are in crisis, call or text 988. For substance use help, the SAMHSA National Helpline is 1-800-662-HELP (4357), and you can search for treatment at FindTreatment.gov.
Holding both truths
We need each other. That part is not in dispute. Rupture will happen, in recovery and in families, because we are human. Repair is a skill, and it gets better with practice.
Take the useful ideas. Leave the hype. You do not have to “reset your vagus” to walk back toward someone you love, or to let someone walk back toward you.
Where in your life is a small repair waiting, and what is one step you could take today?
Sources: Popova, M. “Polyvagal Theory and the Neurobiology of Connection: The Science of Rupture, Repair, and Reciprocity.” The Marginalian, May 3, 2024. https://www.themarginalian.org/2024/05/03/polyvagal-theory/. Porges, S. W. “The polyvagal perspective.” Biological Psychology, 2007;74(2):116-143. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC1868418/. Grossman, P. “Fundamental challenges and likely refutations of the five basic premises of the polyvagal theory.” Biological Psychology, 2023;180:108589. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.biopsycho.2023.108589. Holt-Lunstad, J., Smith, T. B., and Layton, J. B. “Social Relationships and Mortality Risk: A Meta-analytic Review.” PLOS Medicine, 2010;7(7):e1000316. https://journals.plos.org/plosmedicine/article?id=10.1371/journal.pmed.1000316.
This post is for education, not medical advice. It is not a substitute for counseling, trauma treatment, or emergency care. If you or someone you love is struggling with trauma, alcohol, or drugs, please talk with a qualified professional. The free, confidential SAMHSA National Helpline is 1-800-662-4357, and you can search for treatment at FindTreatment.gov. If you are in crisis, call or text 988.
—
AI transparency: I used AI to condense this from my notes and draft and reviewed it before posting. Facts and quotes belong to the original sources (Popova, The Marginalian, 2024; Porges, Biological Psychology, 2007; Grossman, Biological Psychology, 2023; Holt-Lunstad, Smith, and Layton, PLOS Medicine, 2010; and Deb Dana, as quoted in Popova).
Image created with AI assistance.
Keep the conversation going.
Sometimes hearing another person’s experience helps an idea settle in. Explore conversations about recovery, community, and finding a way forward.





